Lawyers for an alleged high-ranking member of the Italian Mafia in Toronto claim evidence is being used against him that is the product of foreign interference by Italian police.
The yearslong case, brought forward by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) and being heard before the Immigration Appeal Division of the Immigration Refugee Board (IRB), seeks to have Vincenzo “Jimmy” DeMaria ruled inadmissible to Canada over claims he is a member of an Italian organized crime group, known as the ‘Nndrangheta, among other unproven allegations.
Documents entered in the case show that a key piece of evidence against DeMaria are recordings of conversations gathered by Italian police, which were eventually provided to the CBSA, that purport to show DeMaria is a member of the ‘Ndrangheta and thus should no longer be allowed to live in Canada.
In a recent application to exclude evidence, DeMaria’s lawyers argue that these conversations were recorded illegally by Italian police, are the product or in furtherance of foreign interference, and should not be permitted in the case.
According to the case file, in 2018, a man by the name of Carmelo Muia, believed by Italian authorities to be a member of the ‘Ndrangheta, was murdered in Calabria — the southernmost region on mainland Italy. This sent Muia’s brother, Vincenzo, on a quest to figure out who was behind the killing.
Italian police documents reveal that what Muia didn’t know was that as part of their own investigation to solve that very same murder, they were listening in on his conversations, after bugging his cell phone. During these conversations, Muia was heard stating that he was going to travel to Canada as part of his mission to solve his brother’s murder.
According to police documents and sources, The Greater Toronto Area (GTA) is considered to be home to one of the strongest concentrations of ‘Ndrangheta members in the world, outside of Calabria. So much so, that Muia believed that alleged members of the ‘Ndrangheta in the GTA may not only be able to confirm who killed his brother, but also authorize him to strike back against the person he thought was responsible — potentially starting a gangland war on the streets of Calabria.
According to documents entered in Demaria’s immigration case, Muia’s plan to travel to Canada was being intercepted by Italian investigators. Eager to gather evidence as part of their investigation into the murder of Muia’s brother, Italian police wanted to continue their eavesdropping on Muia while he was here.
Vincenzo ‘Jimmy’ DeMaria is the subject of a protracted immigration case. If ruled inadmissible to Canada, he will likely be deported to his native Italy (Photo provided)
Documents from DeMaria’s case show that this desire led Italian authorities to ask the Ontario Crown Attorney’s office to obtain a judicial authorization which would permit Italian police to intercept the private communications of Muia while he was on Canadian soil.
The Crown’s response was unequivocal in denying the request. According to the application to exclude evidence, the Crown’s reply to Italian authorities was that there was an “insufficient basis” to approve the intercepts, that the legal threshold was “quite obviously not met” and that “the intrusion of the very high privacy interests of dozens of innocent parties in this case simply cannot be justified…”
The document also indicates that Italian authorities were not pleased with the decision and the Crown attorney himself noted that his legal opinion “did not appear to be well received” by Italian police.
Apparently not.
Despite the request to listen in on Muia while in Canada being denied, Italian police did it anyway.
Italian police records and transcripts of the recordings show that in March 2019, Muia flew to Toronto to embark on his fact-finding mission. Accompanied by other family members, he would spend two weeks in the GTA, with Italian police listening in on his private conversations, even with Canadian citizens, every step along the way.
Records from DeMaria’s immigration case reveal that using online software, Italian police turned Muia’s cell phone into a live listening device, meaning they could monitor conversations through his phone in real time.
They also indicate that simultaneously, York Regional Police (YRP) assisted the Italians and conducted surveillance of Muia and his family members for the duration of their trip, despite being aware the judicial authorization had been denied.
DeMaria’s former lawyer maintained that it would be considered illegal for YRP to have aided Italian police with surveillance with no Canadian judicial authorization in place if they were aware that the intercepts were occurring. Though YRP has stated that they “did not take part in any intercepts for or with the Italian Police…and we were not aware any were taking place.”
DeMaria’s current legal team is arguing that these wiretaps amount to foreign interference and the evidence should be excluded.
In their submission, DeMaria’s lawyer, Jessica Zita, writes: “The YRP interceptions of Muia…were not only illegally obtained, they were also done at the behest of a foreign country. The YRP acted on a request made by the Italian authorities, ignoring the advice of its own counsel…This is a clear-as-day example of a foreign entity successfully exerting pressure on Canadian authorities to act unlawfully on Canadian soil.”
While in the GTA, Muia — who is second cousins with DeMaria — met with numerous people who are also considered by Italian authorities to be associates or members of the ‘Ndrangheta, including DeMaria’s brother. During some of these conversations, which Italian police recorded, Muia could be heard discussing Jimmy DeMaria.
These conversations, which CBSA claim show a tie between DeMaria and organized crime figures, make up part of the basis that Jimmy DeMaria is a member of the ‘Ndrangheta and should be ruled inadmissible to Canada.
“It’s highly unethical,” said David Orman, a Toronto lawyer who concentrates on immigration law – but who is not involved in the case. “It’s improper in these circumstances. They didn’t just do it without asking. They asked, they were told no, and they still did it. Those are aggravating circumstances which very clearly bring the administration of justice into disrepute.”
This isn’t the first time the CBSA has tried to use this information as part of their case to have DeMaria ruled inadmissible to Canada. The CBSA presented it in 2020 as part of disclosure documents against DeMaria.
The IRB panel, which decides admissibility cases, eventually decided in 2023 that the recordings were “…unreliable and lacking in trustworthiness…”
The decision stated the recordings do not “…establish, on reasonable grounds to believe, a clear link between Mr. DeMaria and the ‘Ndrangheta, or that he is a member of that organization. This evidence lacks probative value, and the Panel therefore assigns it no weight in establishing Mr. DeMaria’s membership in the ‘Ndrangheta.”
According to lawyers who work in immigration law, the rules of evidence in immigration cases are less stringent than in criminal matters, thus allowing the material to be continuously re-entered, despite the previous decision that they carry no weight in proving DeMaria is a member of the Mafia.
CTV News contacted the CBSA regarding DeMaria’s case but they replied that they “cannot comment or provide details on specific cases as information is considered private and protected under the Privacy Act..”
For tips on this or any other story email W5 producer Joseph Loiero or call him at 416-859-8617
Canada's ambassador to the United States — and co-lead of the federal government's Team Canada war room — says U.S. president-elect Donald Trump has a different understanding of the bilateral relationship than he did during his first term in the White House.
B.C. health officials say they have detected Canada's first-ever case of H5 avian influenza in a human.
Canada could be an important consensus builder at this year's international climate negotiations, Environment and Climate Change Minister Steven Guilbeault said, while downplaying concerns that Donald Trump's presidential election victory could hamper the talks.
More details have been released about a police investigation at the Ambassador Bridge that connects Windsor, Ont. and Detroit, MI.
Just five more minutes of exercise doesn’t sound so bad, right? Especially when such a small amount may improve your blood pressure, according to a new study.
Shannon Davidson was let go from her executive role at a marketing firm last year after a merger led to cuts. She knew she wasn't done with her career yet, but finding her next workplace in her mid-50s was a daunting prospect.
Brian Avery was three years old when he and his parents packed their belongings into a boat and pulled away from Deer Harbour, N.L., leaving behind their home, their way of life and centuries of family history.
Women are sharing information on social media about a feminist movement in which straight women refuse to marry, have children, date or have sex with men.
A rare letter signed by three of the U.S. Founding Fathers of the United States is going on sale, and is expected to fetch up to US$1 million when it goes under the hammer next week.
A Vancouver designer is making waves in the architectural world with an outdoor modular building created to address the city’s unrelenting housing crisis.
NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh has thrown his weight behind a campaign fighting for better work rights for Kal Tire employees, joining a picket line of workers in Burnaby Saturday morning.
B.C. health officials say they have detected Canada's first-ever case of H5 avian influenza in a human.
Patrons were inside a movie theatre when a suspect fired bullets at the business’ doors on Saturday night, police say.
A man who died in Brampton on Saturday following a “possible stabbing” was actually shot, say Peel police.
On Saturday the City of Calgary held the first of three open houses seeking public input regarding the the intersection and roadways of Sarcee Trail and Bow Trail S.W.
Calgary police are investigating a crash between a minivan and a school bus on Friday.
The soon-to-be-operational Halkirk 2 wind farm was shut down on Friday after a turbine broke.
The Canadian Pacific Kansas City (CPKC) holiday train will be passing through several eastern Ontario cities next month.
Higher-average-temperatures and showers are in the forecast for Ottawa this Sunday.
Many Kanata residents are pushing back against the installation of a tent-like structure to house asylum seekers, holding a rally Saturday to oppose the decision.
It's a century-old tradition that's carried on year after year with pride – we wear a poppy to honour our nation's veterans. But to retired lieutenant-colonel Henry F. Hall it's so much more.
Researchers say taking a peek inside a person's brain is as difficult as understanding the universe or discovering the ocean in its entirety.
A battle is brewing between the city and people who live in Montreal’s Notre-Dame-de-Grâce neighbourhood after it tried to shut off access to a popular wooded area.
A boy is in hospital after being stabbed at a McDonald's in Beaumaris on Friday.
A woman is dead after a driver crashed a truck through a Boston Pizza in Fort McMurray late Saturday morning.
An Alberta municipality says it wants to tell ratepayers how much of their taxes is being spent on policing costs, but Municipal Affairs is taking issue with its disclosure.
New Brunswick health officials are urging residents to get vaccinated after 11 new cases of measles were confirmed in the province.
A new pottery exhibition in Tatamagouche, N.S., is highlighting decades of artwork and the contributions of dozens of creators in the province.
Nova Scotia's New Democratic Party says a candidate criticized by the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs for "troubling" and "damaging" social media posts is no longer running for the party in the Nov. 26 general election.
The countdown to the CFL Western Final is on – and fans of the Winnipeg Blue Bombers and Saskatchewan Roughriders were gearing up for the big game Saturday afternoon.
Some of the most prolific photographers behind CTV Skywatch Pics of the Day use the medium for fun, therapy, and connection.
Manitoba RCMP officers are canvassing an Interlake community this weekend as part of an ongoing homicide investigation.
The Saskatchewan Roughriders extended their Grey Cup drought to 11 years after losing 38-22 to the Winnipeg Blue Bombers in the CFL’s Western Final on Saturday.
The final round of ballots from Saskatchewan’s provincial election were tallied on Saturday, and a race that was previously too close to call has officially been declared.
CTV News Regina will be airing special coverage of Regina’s municipal election on Wednesday evening beginning at 9:30 p.m.
Police say on Nov. 2, two female victims were sexually assaulted by a man in separate incidents.
With University Stadium packed to capacity and an electric atmosphere driving the players, the Golden Hawks delivered an impressive performance, defeating the powerhouse Mustangs and securing their first Yates Cup title since 2016.
Police said officers responded to the area of Christopher Drive and Champlain Boulevard Friday afternoon for a report of a robbery.
The Saskatchewan Roughriders extended their Grey Cup drought to 11 years after losing 38-22 to the Winnipeg Blue Bombers in the CFL’s Western Final on Saturday.
The Regina Rams claimed the Evan Hardy Cup after a hard fought battle against the Saskatoon Huskies 19-14 on Saturday in the first all Saskatchewan U-Sports western conference final since 2002.
Elections Saskatchewan completed the final step in the vote counting process from the provincial election on Saturday.
Police say that a 16-year-old was attacked with a sword Nov. 3 in Cobalt, Ont., in a case of intimate partner violence.
The majority of strokes could be prevented, according to new guidelines aimed at helping people and their doctors do just that.
Police have arrested a 15-year-old in connection with a break-in and $50,000 in damage done to the Centennial Arena in Elliot Lake in September.
More details have been released about a police investigation at the Ambassador Bridge that connects Windsor, Ont. and Detroit, MI.
One by one, students from elementary schools walked to the centre of Vimy Ridge Park in London, Ont. to lay a wreath at the memorial.
The Neighbourhood Decision Making program was launched in 2017 to give Londoners in five areas of the city a chance to submit ideas and earn money to make them come to life.
A former Barrie landlord says she been scammed by a woman recently charged by provincial police with posing as a nurse after allegedly falsifying her credentials to work in long-term care homes.
A heavy police presence has been seen in an Innisfil neighbourhood throughout the day.
Multiple managing partners of Collingwood’s Supportive Rapid Re-Housing Program (SRRP) announced that they will welcome their first residents in the coming weeks.
More details have been released about a police investigation at the Ambassador Bridge that connects Windsor, Ont. and Detroit, MI.
Windsor police attended the Ambassador Bridge for an ongoing investigation Saturday.
Actor Tony Todd, known for his haunting portrayal of a killer in the horror film “Candyman” and roles in many other films and television shows, has died, his longtime manager confirmed. He was 69.
B.C. health officials say they have detected Canada's first-ever case of H5 avian influenza in a human.
Contract negotiations resume today in Vancouver in a labour dispute that has paralyzed container cargo shipping at British Columbia's ports since Monday.
Environment and Climate Change Canada has issued a special weather statement for Metro Vancouver, Howe Sound and parts of the Fraser Valley and Sunshine Coast as another storm approaches.
The emergency department at South Okanagan General Hospital in Oliver, B.C., will be closed for 31 hours this weekend, the second such closure in a week and the third since the start of November.
Police in Kamloops, B.C., are reminding parents and guardians to check their children's Halloween candy after receiving a report of a mother finding a razor blade in one of her daughter's treats.
More than two years after Alannah Brown and Douglas Barker were found dead north of Penticton, police are asking for help identifying a vehicle they believe was associated with the crime.
The Southern Alberta Recreation Association is officially announcing the Town of Taber as next year’s host for the Southern Alberta Summer Games.
The Lethbridge Hurricanes broke open a close game with three goals in the first two minutes of the third period as they defeated the Warriors 7-3 in a game played Friday night in Moose Jaw.
There might not a lot snow just yet, but many southern Albertans are still itching to get outdoors.
Police have arrested a 15-year-old in connection with a break-in and $50,000 in damage done to the Centennial Arena in Elliot Lake in September.
Mayors of the five largest cities in northern Ontario met in North Bay the last two days to discuss a range of critical issues impacting their cities and the region.
Residents in the Sault expressed concerns ranging from vandalism to privacy invasions during recent consultations on the city's plan to install automated speed enforcement cameras.
On Thursday morning, Dave Penny officially ended a suggested hundred-day isolation period that followed his diagnosis and stem cell treatment for non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma. On Thursday night, Penny returned to a stage at a downtown St. John's bar, regaling a small crowd with songs and stories with a distinctive Newfoundland flair.
A Memorial University scientist says the mysterious white blobs washing up on Newfoundland beaches are actually gobs of plastic — and they need to be cleaned up.
School staff are being struck more often, students are fighting more frequently, and police are increasingly being called to school grounds, according to data compiled and released this week by the Newfoundland and Labrador Teachers' Association.
A congestion crisis, a traffic nightmare, or unrelenting gridlock — whatever you call it, most agree that Toronto has a congestion problem. To alleviate some of the gridlock, the Ontario government has announced it plans to remove bike lanes from three major roadways.
For the second year in a row, the ‘Gift-a-Family’ campaign is hoping to make the holidays happier for children and families in need throughout Barrie.
Some of the most prolific photographers behind CTV Skywatch Pics of the Day use the medium for fun, therapy, and connection.
A young family from Codroy Valley, N.L., is happy to be on land and resting with their newborn daughter, Miley, after an overwhelming, yet exciting experience at sea.
As Connor Nijsse prepared to remove some old drywall during his garage renovation, he feared the worst.
A group of women in Chester, N.S., has been busy on the weekends making quilts – not for themselves, but for those in need.
A Vancouver artist whose streetside singing led to a chance encounter with one of the world's biggest musicians is encouraging aspiring performers to try their hand at busking.
Ten-thousand hand-knit poppies were taken from the Sanctuary Arts Centre and displayed on the fence surrounding the Dartmouth Cenotaph on Monday.
A Vancouver man is saying goodbye to his nine-to-five and embarking on a road trip from the Canadian Arctic to Antarctica.
Canada's ambassador to the United States — and co-lead of the federal government's Team Canada war room — says U.S. president-elect Donald Trump has a different understanding of the bilateral relationship than he did during his first term in the White House.
The Public Service Alliance of Canada says the government held a briefing with unions on Thursday to discuss the 'Refocusing Government Spending Initiative." PSAC says, "without prior consultation, the government unilaterally announced their plans to cut costs across the federal public service."
The Supreme Court may have succeeded in sidestepping the request from Droits collectifs Québec (DCQ), which had dragged its registrar before the Federal Court to compel the translation into French of some 6,000 decisions made before 1969 that were only available in English.
Just five more minutes of exercise doesn’t sound so bad, right? Especially when such a small amount may improve your blood pressure, according to a new study.
B.C. health officials say they have detected Canada's first-ever case of H5 avian influenza in a human.
The majority of strokes could be prevented, according to new guidelines aimed at helping people and their doctors do just that.
Elwood Edwards, who voiced America Online’s ever-present 'You’ve got mail' greeting, has died Tuesday at his home in New Bern, N. C. He was 74.
In 1916, Harold Wrong plucked a flower from the fields of Somme, France and tucked it into a letter he mailed home to Toronto. For decades, the type of flower sent remained a mystery.
New technology that was tested at the Assiniboine Park Zoo has arrived in Churchill to help track polar bears.
On Thursday morning, Dave Penny officially ended a suggested hundred-day isolation period that followed his diagnosis and stem cell treatment for non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma. On Thursday night, Penny returned to a stage at a downtown St. John's bar, regaling a small crowd with songs and stories with a distinctive Newfoundland flair.
Kate Winslet shared an anecdote about an encounter she had with someone from her star-making blockbuster film 'Titanic' while producing her new film 'Lee.'
As I see other generations of music lovers say music was so much better when they were younger, I wondered why. We can’t all be right — or maybe we are? I talked to experts in how music influences our brains to find out.
Shannon Davidson was let go from her executive role at a marketing firm last year after a merger led to cuts. She knew she wasn't done with her career yet, but finding her next workplace in her mid-50s was a daunting prospect.
Contract negotiations resume today in Vancouver in a labour dispute that has paralyzed container cargo shipping at British Columbia's ports since Monday.
Televisions that measure 97 inches (and more) diagonally across – a.k.a. XXL TVs – are becoming a huge hit as the cost of giant screens sinks sharply, and viewers look to replace the screens they bought during the peak of the pandemic a few years ago.
A rare letter signed by three of the U.S. Founding Fathers of the United States is going on sale, and is expected to fetch up to US$1 million when it goes under the hammer next week.
Tourists in Rome won't be allowed to toss coins into the Trevi Fountain. A walkway now gives limited access to the monument during maintenance work.
Cynicism is on the rise. Should that come as any surprise given today’s divisive global conflicts and our fraught political landscape? Even the weather seems like it’s out to get us.
A Maui man who lost a part of his leg to a shark bite is now out of the hospital and thanking those who saved his life and helped him recover.
Canadian men's rugby team are ranked 22nd in the world, compared to No. 21 for Chile. Canada faces No. 20 Romania next Saturday.
The Canadian Premier League intends to expand by two teams in 2026.
A driver's trip from London, Ont. to Ottawa to visit their girlfriend ended in a traffic stop for speeding on Highway 417, according to police.
Recall notices have been issued for some Volkswagen models from 2006 to 2019 for airbag safety issues.
Two suspects accused of selling stolen cars while employed at a legitimate car dealership in Toronto are now facing a combined 176 charges, police say.
The Shopping Trends team is independent of the journalists at CTV News. We may earn a commission when you use our links to shop. Read about us.
© 2024 
All rights reserved. Use of this Website assumes acceptance of Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy